Tuesday 21 April 2015

Report on Register of Members’ Interest of Rajya Sabha MPs

​​
Executive Summary
The Register of Members’ Interest, containing details of Rajya Sabha MPs was procured by ADR and NEW through an RTI application. This report analyses the declaration of pecuniary interests of 211 sitting MPs of Rajya Sabha. The report does not go into investigative analysis regarding the business/pecuniary interests of the MPs or whether they are in conflict with the committees they are currently a part of.

Please find attached the detailed report in English.

ADR and NEW have also written to the Prime Minister Shri Narendra Modi and to the Speaker, Smt. Sumitra Mahajan with an appeal to instate the Register of Members’ Interest in the Lok Sabha. Please find attached the letters with the mail.
Rajya Sabha members are required to mention the following types of pecuniary interests:
1.      Remunerative Directorship.
2.      Regular Remunerative Activity.
3.      Shareholding of a Controlling Nature.
4.      Paid Consultancy.
5.      Professional Engagement
​.​
Recommendations of ADR and NEW:
  • A Register of Pecuniary Interests of members of the Lok Sabha should be maintained by the Lok Sabha Secretariat and made available in the public domain.
  • There should be a mechanism for thorough scrutiny and verification into the authenticity of the declarations of financial interest made by members on the ‘form’ of pecuniary interest.
  • The pecuniary details provided in the Register of Interest should be provided to the Income Tax authorities or other appropriate body for cross-checking with the Income Tax Returns filed by the MPs.
  • The business and pecuniary interests of the spouse and dependents should also be declared by the MPs along with their own business interests.
  • No field on the form should be left blank.
  • On the section for ‘Type of Business’ – The description should be exhaustive to include all kinds of activities undertaken by the business.
  • The date of filing the Interest details with the Secretariat should be provided on the form.
On the need for adopting a Register of Members’ Interest in the Lok Sabha, Prof. Jagdeep Chhokar, Founder Member of ADR said that “Disclosure of financial interests by the Rajya Sabha members is encouraging in the public interest. Though the Ethics Committee of the Lok Sabha has recommended adoption of the Register of Interest in the Lok Sabha, but it has not yet been adopted. It will be good if the Lok Sabha adopts it at the earliest”.

Highlights of the report

Based on the declarations in the  Register of Members’ Interest made by 211 sitting MPs of Rajya Sabha, 124 (59%) MPs have declared on the form that they have no pecuniary interest/financial interest whatsoever under any of the five mentioned heads and 87 MPs have declared that they have financial interest under the mentioned heads.

S.No.
Type of declaration
No. of MPs who declared under the head
% of MPs who declared under the head
No. of MPs with no declaration under the head
% of MPs with no declaration under the head
1
Remunerative Directorship
22
10%
189
90%
2
Regular Remunerative Activity
23
11%
188
89%
3
Shareholding of a Controlling Nature
35
17%
176
83%
4
Paid Consultancy
5
2%
206
98%
5
Professional Engagement
39
18%
172
82%
Remunerative Directorship​​
  • 22 MPs have declared that they have some financial interest in the form of Remunerative Directorship of a company and 189 (90%) MPs have declared that they have no financial interest under this head.
    ​​
  • The highest amount received from Remunerative Directorship has been declared by Mr. Vijay Mallya (IND, Karnataka) with value of remunerative directorship of Rs 8.81 crores per annum followed by Mr. Rajeev Chandrashekar (IND Karnataka) with Rs. 6 crore per annum worth remunerative directorship and Mr. D. Kupendra Reddy (JD(S), Karnataka) with Rs. 3.24 crores.
S. No.
Name
Party
State
Total Assets
Total Remunerative Directorship (per annum)
1
Dr.Vijaya Mallya
IND
Karnataka
Rs 6,15,42,41,322
615 crore+
Rs 8,81,23,4338 crore+
2
Rajeev Chandrashekar
IND
Karnataka
Rs 35,86,11,000
35 crore+
Rs 6,00,00,000
6 crore+
3
D. Kupendra Reddy
JD(S)
Karnataka
Rs 4,62,58,96,565
462 crore+
Rs 3,24,00,000
3 crore+
​​
  • The maximum number of directorships have been declared by Mr. Vijay Mallya, an Independent MP from Karnataka with 11 remunerative directorships followed by Dr. Ashok S. Ganguly (Nominated) and Mr. Prabhakar Kore (BJP, Karnataka) with 3. 
Regular Remunerated Activity
  • 23 MPs have declared that they have financial interest in the form of Regular Remunerated Activity and 188 (89%) MPs have no declared financial interests under this head.
  • The highest amount received from regular remunerated activity has been declared by Mr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi (INC, Rajasthan) worth Rs. 82.33 crores followed by Dr. Vijay Mallya (IND, Karnataka) with Rs 2.51 crores per annum and Mr. Yalamanchili Satyanarayana Chowdary (TDP, Andhra Pradesh) with Rs. 1.68 crores as annual income from regular remunerative activity.
Shareholding of controlling nature
  • 35 MPs have declared that they have financial interest in the form of shareholding of a controlling nature and 176 (83%) MPs have declared that they have no financial interest under this head.
  • The highest number of shareholdings of a controlling nature declared in the Register of Interests in companies have been declared by Mr. Dhoot Rajkumar Nandlal (Shiv Sena, Maharashtra) with shares from 31 companies followed by Mr. Kakde Sanjay Dattatraya (IND, Maharashtra) with shares from 30 companies and Mr. Vijay Darda (INC, Maharashtra) with shares from 19 companies. 
S. No.
Name
Party
State
Total Assets
Value of Shares (Self)
Value of Shares (Spouse and Dependents)
Total Value of Shares
(Self and Spouse and dependents)
1
Dhoot Rajkumar Nandlal
Shiv Sena
Maharashtra
Rs 19,28,11,143
19 crore+
Rs. 6,76,73,3326 crore+
Rs 5,91,74,415
5 crore+
Rs. 12,68,47,747
12 crore+
2
Kakde Sanjay Dattatraya
IND
Maharashtra
Rs 4,25,65,86,815
425 crore+
Rs 1,10,83,45,683
110 crore+
Rs. 1,51,62,33,657
151 crore+
Rs. 2,62,45,79,340
262 crore+
3
Vijay Darda
INC
Maharashtra
Rs 49,95,87,060
49 crore+
Rs 4,49,43,025
4 crore+
Rs 1,20,24,804
1 crore+
5,69,67,829
5 crore+
 Paid Consultancy
  • 5 MPs have declared that they have financial interest in the form of Paid Consultancy and 206 (98%) MPs have no declared financial interest under this head.
  • The highest value of benefits derived for all paid consultancy has been declared by Dr. Ashok S. Ganguly (Nominated) with  Rs. 36 lakhs followed by Mr. K.T.S. Tulsi (Nominated) with Rs. 27.50 lakhs and Mr. Narendra Kumar Kashyap (BSP, Uttar Pradesh) with Rs. 10.53 lakhs.
Professional Engagement
  • 39 MPs have declared that they have financial interest in the form of professional engagement and 172 (82%) MPs have no declared financial interest under this head.
  • The highest amount received from professional engagements has been declared by Mr. Sachin Tendulkar (Nominated) with total fees/remuneration received from professional engagements worth Rs 72.79 crores followed by Mr. K.T.S. Tulsi (Nominated) with Rs. 19.13 crores and Mr. Mithun Chakraborty (AITC, West Bengal) with Rs. 16.93 crores.
 MPs with high assets and no declaration of pecuniary interest
  • ​​
    21 MPs with total assets worth more than Rs. 10 crores have declared that they have no pecuniary interests.
  • Four MPs with assets more than Rs. 100 crores have declared no pecuniary interests. These MPs are, Mr. T. Subbarami Reddy (INC, Andhra Pradesh) with Rs. 422.44 crores worth total assets followed by Mr. Arun Jaitley (BJP, Gujarat) with Rs. 120.06 crores, Dr. Karan Singh (INC, NCT of Delhi) with Rs. 116.43 crores and Ms. Mayawati (BSP, Uttar Pradesh) with Rs. 111.64 crores worth of total assets.
S.No.
Name
Party
State
Movable Asset Declarations as per affidavit submitted to ECI at time of election
Immovable Asset Declarations as per affidavit submitted to ECI at time of election
Total Asset Declarations as per affidavit submitted to ECI at time of election
1
​​
T Subbarami Reddy
INC
Andhra Pradesh
Rs 3,00,68,08,224
300 crore+
Rs 1,21,76,50,480
121 crore+
Rs 4,22,44,58,704
422 crore+
2
Shri.Arun Maharajkishen Jaitley
BJP
Gujarat
Rs 39,36,23,153
39 crore+
Rs 80,70,00,000
80 crore+
Rs 1,20,06,23,153
120 crore+
3
Dr. Karan Singh
INC
NCT of Delhi
Rs 21,22,84,325
21 crore+
Rs 95,21,00,000
95 crore+
Rs 1,16,43,84,325
116 crore+
4
Mayawati
BSP
Uttar Pradesh
Rs 15,26,24,840
15 crore+
Rs 96,38,00,000
96 crore+
Rs 1,11,64,24,840
111 crore+

​Regards,​
Media and Journalist Helpline

+91 80103 94248
Maj. Gen. Anil Verma (Retd.)
Head
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
011 4165 4200,
+91 88264 79910
adr@adrIndia.org,
Prof Jagdeep Chhokar
IIM Ahmedabad (Retd.)
Founder Member,
National Election Watch, Association for Democratic
Reforms
+91 99996 20944

Prof Trilochan Sastry
IIM Bangalore
Founder Member,
National Election Watch,
Association for Democratic Reforms
+91 94483 53285


--
Association for Democratic Reforms
T-95A, C.L. House, 1st Floor,
(Near Gulmohar Commercial Complex)
Gautam Nagar
New Delhi-110 049

M: +91 8010394248 
T: +91 11 41654200
F: 011 4609 4248

Web:
-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "National Election Watch News" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to national-ew-news+unsubscribe@googlegroups.com.
To post to this group, send email to national-ew-news@googlegroups.com.
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/national-ew-news.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

No comments:

Post a Comment